4 common mistakes new CEOs make + how to avoid them

As a new CEO, you’ll likely face a range of challenges that can potentially derail your success. From poor communication to micromanagement, these common mistakes can undermine your leadership and weaken company culture. Recognising and avoiding these pitfalls is essential for setting yourself up for success.

Mistake #1: Mistaking busyness for impact

New CEOs often try to drive performance through sheer effort, working long hours and filling their calendars with back-to-back meetings. But this constant busyness compromises the quality of your interactions with team members and stakeholders and leaves little time for strategic thinking. Over time, this lack of thoughtful planning and meaningful engagement will weaken your relationships and lead to poor organisational performance.

Solution: Learn to prioritise effectiveness over mere busyness. Block out time for strategic work and avoid unnecessary meetings that dilute your impact.

Mistake #2: Centralising decision-making

Another common mistake that new CEOs make is assuming their role grants them authority to make all decisions within the company. This approach stifles collaboration and discourages input from across the organisation, lowering overall buy-in and engagement with decisions. The lack of involvement from employees further impacts performance and your company’s ability to achieve its goals.

Solution: Foster a collaborative and inclusive decision-making environment – shared ownership drives better outcomes for your organisation.

Mistake #3: Micromanaging your team

Trying to help with everything – or taking over tasks – can quickly overwhelm your schedule and drive disengagement from those initially responsible for the work. This leads to a decrease in overall team performance, while also pulling you away from strategic decision-making.

Solution: Delegate effectively and empower your team to take ownership of their work while you focus on leading with vision.

Mistake #4: Over-communicating your opinions

Finally, new CEOs often feel compelled to weigh in on every issue, freely expressing their ideas and perspectives. But constant input can limit autonomy and create dependency within your team. Additionally, when employees rely too heavily on your guidance, initiative and innovation suffer.

Solution: Learn to strike a balance between sharing your insights (when they add value) and encouraging independent thought and action from your team.

Strong leadership isn’t about doing it all – it’s about enabling others to thrive. As CEO, this means you need to familiarise yourself with a wide range of techniques to enable you to delegate responsibilities and motivate your employees, rather than shouldering the entire burden of accountability yourself. By adopting a collaborative and engaging culture that prioritises empowerment, you’ll build a high-performing team and drive sustainable success for your company.

Author:

James McLaren
James McLaren

Managing Partner

James is the Founder and Managing Partner of Sterling Black. Previously, he was Managing Partner at Deloitte Leadership Consulting and prior to that was Managing Director, PDI (Korn Ferry). With more than 30 years of experience, James specialises in partnering with Chairs and CEOs. He focuses on review of Board Effectiveness, Chair Feedback and Director Development; CEO and C-Suite Assessment for Selection, Development and Succession; CEO Succession, CEO Coaching and Development.

Recent insights from Sterling Black

Why succession planning fails: 6 board-level mistakes to avoid
Why succession planning fails: 6 board-level mistakes to avoid

Summary To avoid the pitfalls of failed succession planning, boards should: Start early – at least 2 years, but ideally 3–5 years, before a transition. Treat succession as a development process, not...

Is “so” the new “um”? What leaders need to know about filler words
Is “so” the new “um”? What leaders need to know about filler words

Most corporate leaders know to avoid classic filler words like “um” and “uh”. But a subtler verbal tic is quietly eroding executive presence in boardroom briefings, keynote speeches and investor...

Board diversity beyond gender: Rethinking inclusion in Australian leadership
Board diversity beyond gender: Rethinking inclusion in Australian leadership

As the United States rolls back key DEI policies under the Trump administration, the ripple effects are being felt globally. While the Australian legal and cultural frameworks remain more supportive...